Did you complete everything in the game?

I dare to say that morrowind kicks oblivion's ass! Not that Oblivion sucks. But they story and gameplay throughout morrowind was fantastic, No fast travel through map, Find things through the journal. The awesome story! Yet there are major elements which draw down the good features of morrowind as well. Like the fighting system, the draw distance. and The not so fully voiced conversations. But Considering it was made in 2001 It kicks ass.

And Oblivion is better due to the fighting system, the graphics and the physics. But the magic could have been more powerful, They could've kept all the hardcore elements like journal entries and such instead of having the quest compass and all that.

I know you might disagree on this, but this is soloely from my point of view and I will not let you argue about my way of thinking since that is breaking one of the fundamental laws of nature which is "Don't fuck with me!" hehe just kidding.

Suikonde 1 & 2 :D

Jeez that's a tough one.. FF's usually are high up there on lists.. but Stubb saying Morrowind makes me want to lean towards that aswell.

My all time favorites are Final Fantasy 7 and 9, Kingdom Hearts 1 and 2, and Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic.